The following was taped on Saturday from New York City for future airings on Sinclair broadcast affiliates.
* Segment where ROH Champion Dalton Castle announced he was unable to compete, leading to a brawl involving his Boys and The Kingdom.
* Kenny King def. Jonathan Gresham
* Women of Honor: Women of Honor Champion Sumie Sakai and Stella Grey def. Gabby Ortiz and Riley Shepard
* Bully Ray def. Cheeseburger in a No DQ Match. Colt Cabana got involved during the match, brawling with Bully.
* Josh Woods def. Facade. Woods challenged Shane Taylor after.
* Women of Honor: Kelly Klein def. Jenny Rose
* #1 Contenders Gauntlet Match: Kenny King, Chuckie T. and Eli Isom def. SoCal Uncensored, Alex Shelley/Leon St. Giovanni/Jonathan Gresham, The Dawgs/Shane Taylor and ROH TV Champion Silas Young and The Bouncers to become the #1 Contenders to the ROH 6-Man Tag Team Titles.
* Afa Jr. (Former WWE star Manu) won an enhancement match for the Future of Honor YouTube series.
* ROH 6-Man Tag Team Champion Matt Taven (subbing for ROH Champion Dalton Castle) def. Ultimo Guerrero
* Cody w/Brandi Rhodes and Burnard the Business Bear def. Titan. During the match, Cody teased that there would be another ALL IN show next year in New York City, but then ripped on the crowd.
* Jay Lethal def. Chuckie T.
* The Hung Bucks def. ROH Tag Team Champions The Briscoes and Punishment Martinez. The Briscoes attacked The Bucks after until Cody ran out to make the save.
Finally, The Bucks and Cody thanked the crowd and this time legitimately teased that ALL IN 2 might be in New York City, implying it would be in a building a few blocks down from Hammerstein Ballroom, meaning Madison Square Garden, saying it would be something to think about, This closed the tapings.