NXT North American Championship Title History
| Name | Date | Days Held | Location |
| Adam Cole | 4/7/18 | 133 | New Orleans, LA |
| Ricochet | 8/18/18 | 161 | Brooklyn, NY |
| Johnny Gargano | 1/26/19 | 4 | Phoenix, AZ |
| Velveteen Dream | 1/30/19 | 231 | Winter Park, FL |
| Roderick Strong | 9/18/19 | 126 | Winter Park, FL |
| Keith Lee | 1/22/20 | 175 | Winter Park, FL |
| Vacated | 7/15/20 | — | Winter Park, FL |
| Damian Priest | 8/22/20 | 67 | Winter Park, FL |
| Johnny Gargano | 10/28/20 | 14 | Orlando, FL |
| Leon Ruff | 11/11/20 | 25 | Orlando, FL |
| Johnny Gargano | 12/6/20 | 163 | Orlando, FL |
| Bronson Reed | 5/18/21 | 42 | Orlando, FL |
| Isaiah “Swerve” Scott | 6/29/21 | 105 | Orlando, FL |
| Carmelo Hayes | 10/12/21 | 172 | Orlando, FL |
| Cameron Grimes | 4/2/22 | 63 | Dallas, TX |
| Carmelo Hayes | 6/4/22 | 101 | Orlando, FL |
| Solo Sikoa | 9/13/22 | 7 | Orlando, FL |
| Vacated | 9/20/22 | — | Orlando, FL |
| Wes Lee | 10/22/22 | 269 | Orlando, FL |
| “Dirty” Dominik Mysterio | 7/18/23 | 74 | Orlando, FL |
| Trick Williams | 9/30/23 | 3 | Bakersfield, CA |
| “Dirty” Dominik Mysterio | 10/3/23 | 67 | Orlando, FL |
| Dragon Lee | 12/9/23 | 31 | Bridgeport, CT |
| Oba Femi | 1/9/24 | C | Orlando, FL |